The webseries turned TV-Movie turned webseries turned TV-movie turned Blu-ray.
Ron Moore and David Eick’s Battlestar Galactica was such an amazing show that any spinoffs of it are going to have a lot to live up to. BSG was sci-fi at its best – using its otherworldly setting to tell very human stories that deeply resonated emotionally and touched upon current events without feeling preachy.
The latest spinoff project, Battlestar Galactica: Blood & Chrome, had a long journey to reach viewers. It was first intended as a webseries, then reconceived as a TV-Movie pilot for an ongoing series, only for Syfy to pass on it. Afer sitting on the shelf for quite awhile, it finally debuted a couple of months ago… as webisodes, amusingly, and is at last airing as a full-length standalone TV-Movie on Syfy on Sunday, February 10th, before its Blu-ray release on February 19th.
I watched the first three or four webisodes when they debuted, but disliked seeing an ongoing story cutting off so frequently mid-scene – and knowing it was going to air on Syfy soon made it easier to wait to see the whole thing. But truth be told, Blood & Chrome, unfortunately, wasn’t grabbing me enough to have to see what happened next…
Caprica was an attempt at a BSG prequel/spinoff with a very different vibe and setting from the series that begat it, but with that show a commercial failure, Blood & Chrome goes in a very different direction. Caprica was mostly planet-bound and soap opera in its approach. Blood & Chrome is a war story, taking the BSG story back into space and featuring a lot of action and human vs. Cylon combat.
The story focuses on William Adama (Luke Pasqualino) as a very green, just out of training pilot assigned to, yes, the Battlestar Galactica. Eager to fight as a Viper pilot, Adama is upset when he is instead made a Raptor pilot, sent with co-pilot Coker (Ben Cotton) to transport scientist Dr. Becca Kelly (Lili Bordan) on what he considers to be a “milk run.” But Dr. Kelly is more important than she appears, with a top secret mission that could prove to be a crucial turning point in the ongoing war against the Cylons.
With Caprica’s failure, perhaps it’s understandable Syfy and Eick (Moore did not take part in Blood & Chrome) would push hard in the opposite direction here. But Blood & Chrome often feels like a hollow version of Battlestar. Yes, that show had awesome combat scenes, but it also delved into far more cerebral territory and also, quite notably, spiritual territory, often represented by the robotic Cylons, no less. Caprica got better and better as it progressed (ending with a run of excellent episodes) but also announced from the start it was delving into some heady space, involving the idea what constitutes a soul and how much a virtual version of someone could recapture who they truly were.
Blood & Chrome is about the war, which is fine and something, in theory, many of us were excited to see play out… but it is notably lacking in those deeper aspects that made Battlestar so special. It’s got much more of a Star Wars vibe — including its trio of the young, energetic guy, the older cynical guy and the headstrong gal on a mission of her own –- down to its structure, which is very old school serial, as Adama, Coker and Kelly encounter one obstacle after another, from enemy ships to a serpent-like creature. Star Wars is awesome, but the Ron Moore version of Battlestar Galactica was an incredibly different animal, despite the original 1970s BSG being created in Star Wars’ shadow. The attempt to turn one into the other (this is the same continuity as Moore’s series after all) feels odd.
What’s notably lacking is much in the way of nuanced character building, except in a cursory manner. This is especially prominent with some of the characters Adama and Coker encounter, who are given huge moments played with a lot of drama — including loyal soldiers willing to go down with their ship or a guy who has an emotional whirlwind learning about the son he never knew he had — with almost no time establishing them beforehand to give what is happening any weight.
Unfortunately, the man at the center of it all remains at arm’s length as well. If you’re a BSG fan, of course, you’ll care that this is William Fraking Adama, but little onscreen helps invest us in him beyond the modicum of seeing him show off his pilot skills and attempt to bond with the crusty Coker and the guarded Kelly. It also doesn’t help that it is extremely difficult to see Pasqualino as playing the same character Edward James Olmos played. Yes, obviously the idea is this is a young, callow Adama with a lot to learn and that we’d see him toughen up as the series (had it been ordered) continued. But Pasqualino doesn’t look like, sound like or carry himself like Olmos and it seems impossible to chart this specific kid becoming that man.
Until the very end of the TV-movie, Blood & Chrome also stays very rooted with the human side of things, not delving into the Cylon’s POV. There are a couple of tidbits in the final moments that hint at future stories that would have gone back into the Cylon story more, but this introduction to BSG: B&C is much more about military missions and little else, lacking much of what made Moore’s series feel so fully formed.
I feel like I’ve harped on Blood & Chrome more than I meant to. It’s not bad and has some fun action scenes (I really liked the visuals in an aerial battle through the clouds in one sequence), and while the budget was clearly an issue when it came to the FX on the green screen shot production, the show has a nice visual style. However, it’s worth noting the FX do vary considerably, from fairly strong to rather blatantly fake, depending on the moment and scene.
In the “small things count” category, it was nice to see the big possible romance in the story between the young Adama and the clearly older, widowed Dr. Kelly, given it’s usually only when the genders are reversed that such a thing is played so casually. Also, Cotton does solid work as Coker, adding tinges of poignancy to the character throughout. John Pyper-Ferguson also has fun as a soldier our trio encounter on an ice planet, while also managing to achieve the cool trivia of having appeared in different roles in Battlestar Galactica, Caprica and now Blood & Chrome.
Along with some nice nods to Caprica early on (Graystone Industries and the Ha’la’tha are both referenced), Battlestar fans will likely enjoy the last act of Blood & Chrome the most. Not only is it when the Cylon side of things get touched upon in a bigger way, but it also, in other areas, opens the door to circumstances not being as clear cut as they seem when it comes to fighting a war, as the idea of propaganda and selling something in a very skewed way is evoked. While the movie overall is just okay, those final moments do hint that perhaps the ongoing series, had it occurred, could have gone to more interesting places.
The Blood & Chrome Blu-ray features a decent transfer. There is a grainy, “You are there” look that is purposeful (and in line with Battlestar), but there is little doubt this show, with it’s strange back and forth from webseries to TV-Movie and back again, was relatively low-budget despite its ambition. That being said, the transfer itself is solid with strong colors and shading. The DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 is very good, nicely displaying another strong score by Bear McCreary and all the requisite Cylon and Galactica sound FX.
The extras are fairly minimal, though better than they appear at a glance. The only behind-the-scenes inclusion is a featurette focused on the visual FX, but it’s actually longer than you’d expect at 23 minutes, including interviews with Eick and other producers, along with the FX team. It delves into the conception of Blood & Chrome and spotlights all the work that went into the green screen production. While a commentary or more story-oriented discussion would have been great, this at least does get into the nitty gritty of production on the project.
The only other special feature are deleted scenes, but there are actually a ton of them, running the better part of a half hour. Some are inconsequential moments, but there are several – mostly taken out from the opening portion of the movie – that would have been highly appreciated if they’d been kept in, better building who Adama and Coker are before the action begins. The vast majority of the deleted scenes were never finished, so you can see the green screen surrounding the cast, making the difference between those scenes and the finished project more impressive and notable.
The Blu-ray is the “unrated” version. While essentially the same as what is airing on TV, it features a bit more footage, including, yep, one pair of bare breasts during a co-ed shower scene onboard Galactica and a bit more harsh language.
Having finally seen Blood & Chrome, I can’t say I’m horribly upset it didn’t get picked up to series (and I still miss Caprica!). However, there are moments though that reminded me of how much I loved this world and that I wouldn’t mind if somehow we do return to it again at some point.